Album highlight “I Love You” shows how much Aalegra can accomplish with just a few words. She mostly repeats the titular phrase, but holds your attention by shifting the tenor slightly each time: Sometimes, her voice sounds airy and trepidatious; elsewhere, her honeyed lower register is incredibly tender and assured. The song evokes a sense of emotional release, of ease after a period of struggle, and her voice is propelled by lush, euphoric production. Synths twinkle as they love to do, legendary disco and funk guitarist Nile Rodgers contributes his classic percussive and syncopated playing, and a warm, lilting bass line (performed by yet another icon and fellow Prince protege, Raphael Saadiq) rounds out the sound.
“Warmest Shade of Blue,” a glimmering ballad about unexpressed romantic feelings, showcases Aalegra’s sense of timing. “On the surface I come off as cold/But I’m the warmest shade of blue,” she sings across a gentle drum machine and a lonesome synth that sounds like the wind whistling between the mountains. Her voice lags slightly behind the beat like a lover lingering in your doorway as the party dies down, contemplating divulging the extent of their feelings. Listening to the song, I’m reminded of Arooj Aftab, who quietly builds on a sense of longing throughout a track until it completely envelops you. Both singers exhibit the kind of vocal patience and control that makes it feel like they could shift the tides if they wanted to.
There are moments where the record is too slick, where the glossiness feels dampening and homogenizing rather than illuminating. The closer, “Greatest of All Time,” is a song about mourning the loss of an imagined future as a relationship ends. Lyrically, it’s full of bargaining and regret. Aalegra’s vocals tumble. Synths crescendo. A backing choir comes in to underscore her words. Every instrument is perfectly arranged, but the heartache sounds far away. The production is almost too clean, optimized for harmony in a way that eliminates friction, unpredictability, and intrigue. Similarly, slow-burning ballad “Karma” floats by, guitar glinting like tinsel on a Christmas display, without leaving much of an impact. Production this referential and consistent—both across the record and in R&B writ large—can easily feel a bit premeditated, making the emotional arc of the songs predictable.
