The first sound you hear on Beginningless is static crackling in warm fuzz, a sound you might get if you were to slowly drag a microphone against a fabric surface. This is bassist Anna Butterss, trumpeter John Raymond, and drummer Ben Lumsdaine’s first album together, but the way each member locks in to play off that amorphous residue suggests a shared alertness to the finer details. While Butterss and Raymond are best known for their playful adventures via the Chicago-based International Anthem label—the former in SML and Jeff Parker’s ETA IVtet, and the latter with a 2023 solo album, Murmuration Without End—all three have connections to the scene around Indiana University, where a joint set in 2024 was explosive enough to get them in a studio to flesh out a full-length release. On their debut album, the three players find common ground in the allure of repeated motifs. Their ears are turned toward textural nuances; they use the expansive energy of passing minutiae to create recurring phrases that stick.
Improvised live in the studio, Beginningless homes in on the way each musician reacts to the others. Across the album’s 37 minutes, the trio creeps around ghostly modes with a mostly acoustic setup. The soundscape is moody and umbral, awash in middling tempos and cool tones. They are sparing with their use of electronics, which are mainly detectable through subtle knob movements—in the way delays make little tinny particles out of hi-hats, and filter sweeps simulate gusts of wind carrying away the few melodies that are being played. The album especially dazzles in its groove-forward approach to fleeting ambience.
No score yet, be the first to add.
With meditative focus, the trio strikes a hallucinatory balance of potential and kinetic energy. “Parallax” is a prime example: The rhythm section focuses on the immersive depth of gorp jazz and the horn melodies hang with chilly restraint. Butterss’ distorted bass is thicker than a bowl of oatmeal, and its dubbiness creates a hefty ripple effect that pushes against the other instruments. They occupy an interesting role, holding down the beat while also taking the lead, however fragmentary the melody. Lumsdaine’s drumming mostly chugs along, occasionally skittering into smaller ideas for variation. What ties it all together is Raymond’s sweet, spaced-out playing, shrouding everything in a psychedelic, out-of-body dissociative state. A similar thing happens on the title track, with Butterss and Lumsdaine doubled up on rhythm, as if to emphasize the impossibility of pinning down the silky-smooth brass. It’s a pleasure to experience the slow melodic development, anticipating what sweet or sour notes Raymond will push through his sustain pedal to harmonize over.
