There are two unassailable highlights. First is “All the Way to Reno (You’re Gonna Be a Star),” with its exquisite bridge and Peter Buck’s Byrdsian guitar, here recalling “So You Want to Be a Rock ’n’ Roll Star.” And “Imitation of Life” is one of the band’s greatest moments, a song that would’ve been a perfect fit on any R.E.M. album from Document forward, unfurling a lush hyperreality that lives up to the Douglas Sirk film it clearly takes its name from (a big influence on Stipe’s pal Todd Haynes, who would begin writing his Sirk tribute, Far From Heaven, later that year). Giddy and terrified, “Imitation of Life” piles hooks atop hooks, Stipe hollering happy words—“sugarcane,” “lemonade,” “cinnamon,” “Hollywood”—while staring down “this lightning storm/This tidal wave/This avalanche” and insisting tremulously “I’m not afraid” like a kid coaching himself off the brink of tears.
Other standouts refract and embellish the singles. The Brian Wilson mash note “Summer Turns to High” is a balmy conjuring of the season, “Chorus and the Ring” a cryptic deep cut that deepens if you know its backstory involving William S. Burroughs and Kurt Cobain. In the reissue’s booklet essay, journalist Birgit Fuss admires the LP’s many female characters and singles out “Now is greater than the whole of the past,” from “She Just Wants to Be,” as a particularly tattoo-worthy lyric. But even as his verse-writing bloomed over time, Stipe remained a tone poet above all, his keened hollers communicating ache, hunger, yearning and ecstasy well beyond his words.
The band never did a proper tour for Reveal, but they did do some European promo gigs, including the Radio France “Black Sessions” included in the bonus material here. The expanded band features the core stringers from Reveal—Joey Waronker, Ken Stringfellow and Scott McCaughey. It doesn’t sound like the classic R.E.M. quartet, and that’s fine. The new songs flex their newness: the squishy synths on “I’ve Been High” get dialed up higher than on Reveal’s studio version; tiki lounge bongos strut on “All The Way to Reno (You’re Gonna Be a Star).” And old songs get plumped up fruitfully, “So. Central Rain (I’m Sorry)” with organ gravitas and “It’s the End of the World as We Know It (and I Feel Fine)” with barrelhouse piano and massed vocals, both songs reasserting Stipe’s love of parentheticals and transcendent way of riding a melody’s crest. The session suggests a band enjoying its own reinvention, which wasn’t initially the case. (Stipe has described the making of Up, their first trio LP, as “a horrible, horrible experience.”)
Daniel D`Amico for SANREMO.FM
